# Does Our Brain Really Age Because of Time… Or Because We Stop Giving It What It Needs?
**Neuroplasticity, carnivore nutrition, vitamin B12, cholesterol, and ketone bodies: Dr. Anthony Chaffee’s insights on brain aging.**
*By Laurent Glatz — Athletic Carnivore News*
We almost instinctively accept that as we age, our brain gradually shrinks, our memory becomes less reliable, and our cognitive abilities decline.
But one question deserves to be asked: **what if part of this decline is not an inevitable biological fate?**
This is precisely the topic addressed by Dr. Anthony Chaffee during a conference focused on neuroplasticity and brain nutrition, which we followed with great interest.
His reasoning is based on a simple idea: a brain cannot function properly, develop, or repair its structures if it lacks the necessary elements.
Among these elements, he places particular emphasis on fats, cholesterol, B vitamins, animal nutrients, and ketone bodies.
In other words, what we eat could influence not only our metabolic health but also how our brain ages.
This hypothesis is especially interesting for us at Athletic Carnivore, where we have worked for years on the relationships between nutrition, metabolism, performance, and neurological function.
Anthony Chaffee: A Physician, Athlete, and Advocate of Animal-Based Nutrition
Before examining his conference, it is important to understand the background of its author.
Dr. Anthony Chaffee is an American physician practicing in Australia. He began his university studies at 16 in molecular and cellular biology, with additional training in chemistry, at the University of Washington.
He then pursued his medical degree at the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland.
His experience includes neurosurgery, with a stint at Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital in Perth, as well as a practice focused on metabolic health.
Alongside his medical career, Anthony Chaffee has significant athletic experience.
A former All-American rugby player, he played professionally in the United States and England. He also practiced mixed martial arts.
This dual medical and athletic background helps explain his particular interest in nutrition, physical performance, recovery, and the physiological mechanisms linked to diet.
Today, he leads clinical operations at Elevate Medical Center and hosts *The Plant Free MD*, a podcast dedicated to nutrition, metabolism, and chronic diseases.
For several years, he has advocated a diet based primarily, if not exclusively, on animal products.
His approach is grounded in his clinical practice, personal experience, and interpretation of scientific publications, which he regularly presents at international conferences.
This does not mean all his conclusions have the same level of evidence. But his background and clinical experience make his presentation particularly worth examining.
The Brain Has an Underestimated Ability: To Transform Itself
Neuroplasticity refers to the nervous system’s ability to modify its organization, connections, and certain functional aspects.
For a long time, the adult brain was portrayed as an organ with relatively limited capacity for change.
We now know this view was incomplete.
The brain can adapt its neural networks in response to learning, training, certain injuries, or environmental changes.
Anthony Chaffee emphasizes a crucial point: this plasticity works both ways.
A supportive environment can foster brain adaptation. Conversely, unfavorable conditions can contribute to neurological decline.
He distinguishes several mechanisms: energy supply, availability of materials needed for brain structures, stimuli that promote adaptation, and reduction of factors that can damage cells.
**A brain is therefore not just a quantity of neurons. It is also a network of connections that must be maintained.**
This distinction is fundamental to understanding the rest of his talk.
Why Does Our Brain Shrink with Age?
One of the most interesting parts of the presentation concerns differences observed between human brain aging and that of chimpanzees.
Anthony Chaffee refers to a 2011 study published in the *Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences*.
Researchers compared brain structures of 99 chimpanzees aged 10 to 51 and 87 humans aged 22 to 88.
They observed a decrease in volume in several brain regions in older humans, without a comparable reduction in the chimpanzees studied.
The speaker then asks: why consider this decrease as necessarily a normal evolution?
He suggests that our environment and diet could contribute to the phenomenon.
However, the original study provides an important clarification: the authors mainly attribute this difference to human longevity, which exceeds that of chimpanzees. Thus, the comparison does not prove that modern diet causes brain atrophy.
For Athletic Carnivore, the real question is not to deny biological aging but to identify the potentially modifiable part of this aging.
Age plays a role, but nutritional deficiencies, metabolic disorders, physical activity, vascular diseases, and lifestyle habits can also influence brain trajectory.
Ketone Bodies: A Long-Underestimated Fuel for the Brain
This is probably one of the most important parts of the conference.
We generally know glucose as a major energy source for the brain.
Yet neurons have another option: using ketone bodies, especially beta-hydroxybutyrate.
These molecules are mainly produced by the liver when carbohydrate availability decreases and the body mobilizes more fat.
Under certain prolonged ketosis conditions, ketone bodies can supply a significant portion of the brain’s energy.
Anthony Chaffee reminds us that this capacity also plays a physiological role during early life stages.
Newborns can produce and use ketone bodies despite the presence of carbohydrates in breast milk.
He also stresses their involvement in metabolism necessary for brain development.
A clarification is necessary: this does not mean glucose is useless, nor that ketone bodies are always the brain’s preferred fuel in all circumstances.
Their importance depends notably on their availability and the organism’s metabolic state.
However, their ability to provide an alternative energy source is a serious avenue in certain neurological diseases.
Alzheimer’s: When the Brain No Longer Properly Uses Glucose
Alzheimer’s disease is often accompanied by decreased cerebral glucose metabolism.
This abnormality can appear relatively early in the disease’s progression.
Anthony Chaffee points out that a brain whose some cells use glucose less efficiently could still utilize ketone bodies.
This has led several teams to study ketogenic diets, medium-chain triglycerides, and exogenous ketones.
Early results are promising.
Some studies observed improvements in memory tests or cognitive function, especially in people with mild cognitive impairment.
However, other trials show more modest results or face significant adherence challenges.
A meta-analysis of 12 randomized trials with 707 participants reported an average improvement in overall cognitive function and certain memory domains.
This is an encouraging scientific signal, without proving to date that ketosis can cure Alzheimer’s or definitively reverse neurodegeneration.
At Athletic Carnivore, we mainly retain the energy mechanism: **a nutritional intervention capable of altering the fuels available to the brain deserves serious study.**
Vitamin B12: One of the Most Convincing Demonstrations
Anthony Chaffee gives a central role to vitamin B12.
On this subject, we have particularly interesting human data.
Vitamin B12 is involved in nervous system function, notably in maintaining myelin, the structure that surrounds many nerve fibers and facilitates electrical signal transmission.
A deficiency can cause neurological disorders, cognitive problems, and sometimes severe damage.
In 2008, a team from Oxford University published a study on 107 adults aged 61 to 87, followed for five years.
Participants with the lowest B12 concentrations had a significantly higher risk of substantial brain volume loss.
The group with the lowest levels had about six times the risk of marked brain atrophy compared to those with the highest levels.
Particularly interesting: these participants did not necessarily have a deficiency according to usual thresholds.
The study raises a question about the relationship between blood B12 levels and long-term neurological health.
However, this is an observational association: it alone does not determine an optimal universal concentration nor prove that systematic supplementation would prevent brain atrophy.
What This Means for the Carnivore Diet
Meats, fish, eggs, and some dairy products provide naturally bioavailable vitamin B12.
Liver and several organ meats contain particularly high concentrations.
A well-composed carnivore diet can thus supply significant amounts of this vitamin.
However, dietary intake must be distinguished from absorption: some digestive pathologies or treatments can cause deficiency even when intake is sufficient.
Cholesterol and the Brain: An Essential Structural Element
Cholesterol often sparks debate in nutrition discussions.
But its role in the nervous system is indisputable.
It participates in forming cell membranes, myelin, and the functioning of neuronal connections.
The brain has its own cholesterol metabolism, largely distinct from blood circulation.
Anthony Chaffee emphasizes this biological necessity before discussing lipid-lowering treatments, especially statins.
He recalls that memory problems have been reported in some patients treated with these drugs.
This issue deserves study, but the largest controlled trials and meta-analyses do not show a general increase in cognitive impairment risk linked to statins.
A meta-analysis published in 2026 covering 42 trials and over 150,000 participants found no overall adverse effect of lipid-lowering treatments on cognitive functions.
We must therefore distinguish possible individual side effects from the claim that these drugs systematically degrade the brain.
For Athletic Carnivore, the most important lesson remains that cholesterol is an essential biological component whose cerebral role should not be confused with the LDL concentration measured in blood alone.
Choline, Creatine, Taurine, DHA: Other Essential Nutrients for Neurological Function
The talk is not limited to vitamin B12.
Anthony Chaffee presents several nutrients involved in brain functions.
Choline is involved in synthesizing acetylcholine, a neurotransmitter, and in forming cell membranes.
DHA, an omega-3 fatty acid, is abundant in neuronal membranes.
Creatine contributes to rapid energy availability in cells, including the nervous system.
Taurine participates in several cellular and neurological mechanisms.
Vitamin A, vitamin D, and other micronutrients also contribute through various mechanisms to normal body function.
These elements have different functions; they should not be considered interchangeable or universal neurological treatments.
However, several animal foods naturally provide a significant portion of these nutrients.
This is a central nutritional argument of the carnivore approach: the nutrient density of certain foods, their bioavailability, and the possibility of simultaneously obtaining multiple compounds necessary for human function.
BDNF: Why Moving, Learning, and Training Also Protect Our Brain
The conference addresses another fascinating mechanism: BDNF, or *Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor*.
This protein is involved in neuronal survival, synaptic plasticity, and mechanisms linked to learning and memory.
Anthony Chaffee explains that several stimuli can influence its expression, notably physical exercise and certain metabolic changes.
This is particularly interesting when linking nutrition and training.
Physical activity does not only stimulate muscle mass or cardiovascular capacity.
It also acts on the nervous system.
Endurance exercises, strength training, certain intense activities, and motor learning can contribute to brain adaptation.
Learning new skills, sleep, and social interactions complete this approach.
At Athletic Carnivore, we have long considered that **nutrition and training should not be analyzed separately**.
Nutrition provides energy and nutrients. Physical activity imposes adaptive demands. Recovery allows the body to respond to these challenges.
This combination seems particularly important to us.
Epilepsy, Multiple Sclerosis, Parkinson’s: How Far Can Nutrition Go?
Anthony Chaffee then presents various neurological diseases for which ketogenic interventions have been studied.
Situations must be distinguished.
Pharmacoresistant epilepsy benefits from longstanding clinical experience and relatively solid evidence regarding specialized ketogenic diets, especially in children.
For Alzheimer’s disease, research is promising but still insufficient to demonstrate lasting clinical efficacy.
Regarding multiple sclerosis, several studies have examined the effects of carbohydrate restriction on fatigue, quality of life, and some clinical parameters.
A randomized trial published in 2025 followed 105 people with relapsing multiple sclerosis, comparing different nutritional strategies over 18 months.
These studies allow examination of potential effects but do not prove that a ketogenic diet can replace disease-modifying treatments or systematically prevent lesion development.
For Parkinson’s, Huntington’s, and other neurological diseases, human data remain more limited.
The common thread in these studies is interesting: many neurological diseases involve energy, inflammatory, or cellular disturbances.
It is therefore coherent to study interventions that may influence these mechanisms, without assuming all these diseases have a single cause.
Could Processed Foods Also Contribute to the Problem?
Anthony Chaffee also examines several environmental factors.
He notably mentions excess sugars, certain dietary fats, pesticides, periodontal infections, and the consequences of excessive screen exposure.
These topics do not all have the same level of evidence or mechanisms.
Scientific literature shows that metabolic health, cardiovascular health, physical activity, and various environmental exposures can influence cognitive decline risk.
It would be excessive to automatically attribute neurological diseases to a single ingredient or entire food category.
But it would be equally reductive to consider that our dietary environment has no impact on brain function.
Athletic Carnivore’s Perspective: What This Conference Really Teaches Us
Our carnivore nutrition approach is based on several principles that this presentation allows us to examine from a neurological angle.
**First, nutritional density.**
A diet based on animal products can provide complete proteins, vitamin B12, zinc, heme iron, choline, creatine, and several other important nutrients.
**Second, metabolic flexibility.**
The human body can use different energy sources. The availability of ketone bodies represents an additional possibility particularly interesting in certain neurological contexts.
**Third, reduction of ultra-processed foods.**
Switching from a diet rich in industrial products to one composed of simple foods can simultaneously modify several nutritional and metabolic factors.
**Fourth, association with physical activity.**
No nutritional model replaces the effects of muscular, cardiovascular, and cognitive stimulation.
One of our points of attention concerns the difference between a ketogenic diet and a strict carnivore diet.
Studies demonstrating some neurological benefits of ketosis do not automatically prove the superiority of an exclusively animal-based diet.
A scientific review published in January 2026, specifically dedicated to the carnivore diet, identified only nine human studies and highlights the lack of long-term data.
Another nutritional composition study published in 2025 shows that several carnivore models can meet certain recommended intakes, but their adequacy strongly depends on the foods chosen.
It remains important to study different versions of this diet rather than consider them identical.
What interests us is understanding which mechanisms produce the observed effects: carbohydrate restriction, ketosis, protein intake, micronutrient composition, reduction of processed foods, or a combination of these factors.
The Real Question: Can We Influence Our Brain’s Trajectory?
What makes Anthony Chaffee’s presentation interesting is not only his defense of the carnivore diet.
It is especially how he connects several domains often studied separately: nutrition, energy production, neuronal structure, metabolism, physical exercise, and aging.
We know nutritional deficiencies can damage the nervous system.
We know the brain can use ketone bodies.
We know exercise stimulates mechanisms linked to brain plasticity.
We also know some nutritional interventions are currently being tested in clinical trials for various neurological diseases.
Much remains to be discovered about the extent of their effects, who might benefit, and their long-term efficacy.
But one question remains: **if we paid as much attention to the metabolic and nutritional needs of our brain as we do to our muscles, could our aging process be different?**
This question, far more than a simple opposition between diets, now deserves our attention.
---
Key Scientific Studies
1. **Sherwood CC et al. (2011)** — *Aging of the cerebral cortex differs between humans and chimpanzees.* PNAS. Comparative study of 99 chimpanzees and 87 humans. DOI: [10.1073/pnas.1016709108](https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1016709108).
2. **Vogiatzoglou A et al. (2008)** — *Vitamin B12 status and rate of brain volume loss in community-dwelling elderly.* Neurology. Prospective study of 107 individuals followed for five years. DOI: [10.1212/01.wnl.0000325581.26991.f2](https://doi.org/10.1212/01.wnl.0000325581.26991.f2).
3. **Bahr LS et al. (2025)** — *Fasting, ketogenic, and anti-inflammatory diets in multiple sclerosis: a randomized controlled trial with 18-month follow-up.* BMC Nutrition. DOI: [10.1186/s40795-025-01156-5](https://doi.org/10.1186/s40795-025-01156-5).
4. **2024 Controlled Trial** — *A randomized feasibility trial of the modified Atkins diet in older adults with mild cognitive impairment due to Alzheimer's disease.* [PubMed — 38505743](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38505743/).
5. **2026 Meta-Analysis** — *The effects of cholesterol-lowering drugs on neurocognitive function: systematic review and meta analysis.* Analysis of 42 controlled trials and 150,405 participants. [Scientific Publication](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12913106/).
6. **2026 Review** — *Carnivore Diet: A Scoping Review of the Current Evidence, Potential Benefits and Risks.* Nutrients. DOI: [10.3390/nu18020348](https://doi.org/10.3390/nu18020348).
7. **2025 Study** — *Assessing the Nutrient Composition of a Carnivore Diet: A Case Study Model.* [PubMed — 39796574](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39796574/).
**About the Speaker:** [Official website of Dr. Anthony Chaffee](https://dranthonychaffee.com/about), physician practicing in Australia and host of *The Plant Free MD*.
---
**Keywords:** neuroplasticity, brain, Dr. Anthony Chaffee, carnivore diet, ketogenic diet, B12, Alzheimer’s, ketones, BDNF, cholesterol, brain aging, neurological nutrition, Athletic Carnivore.
Discussion around this article
Ask a question or add your feedback directly below the article. The comment appears on the page and can be removed from the admin area if needed.
No comment published yet. Start the discussion.