Athletic Carnivore News

Starch: Understanding Its Three Types That Influence Digestion and Blood Sugar

Starch is not uniform: impact on blood sugar and gut microbiota

Auteur : Laurent Glatz Publié : 2026-11-16 Catégorie : Carnivore Nutrition

# STARCH: YOU’VE HEARD ABOUT GLYCEMIC INDEX, BUT THE THREE CATEGORIES THAT CHANGE EVERYTHING ARE OFTEN OVERLOOKED

**By Laurent Glatz – for Athletic Carnivore**

For decades, we've been told that simple carbohydrates are quickly absorbed while complex carbohydrates provide more gradual energy. We hear about sugar, glycemic index, whole grains, white rice, or bread. Yet, a far more insightful classification remains largely absent from dietary discussions.

**In reality, scientists distinguish three starch fractions based on their behavior during digestion. Their physiological effects can be radically different.**

Two foods can contain comparable amounts of starch yet release glucose at very different rates. Even more intriguingly, depending on preparation, the proportions of rapidly digestible, slowly digestible, and resistant starch in the same food can vary.

This is not a recent theory. This classification was formalized in 1992 by researchers Englyst, Kingman, and Cummings. It distinguishes rapidly digestible starch (RDS), slowly digestible starch (SDS), and resistant starch (RS).

A fundamental clarification: these three categories do not represent perfectly separate food families. A single food can contain all three fractions in varying proportions.

FIRST CATEGORY: RAPIDLY DIGESTIBLE STARCH, OR RDS

This is probably the most relevant fraction when discussing blood sugar, insulin secretion, and rapid glucose availability.

RDS, or *Rapidly Digestible Starch*, corresponds to the starch fraction hydrolyzed within the first twenty minutes of a standardized enzymatic test conducted in the lab.

These twenty minutes do not represent an exact timer of human digestion. It is an experimental measure used to compare foods.

In the body, digestive enzymes—especially pancreatic amylase—gradually break down starch chains. The products of this breakdown are then converted into glucose, absorbed in the small intestine.

The more accessible the starch is to enzymes, the faster this glucose release can be.

Which foods are particularly involved?

White breads made from finely milled flour, many puffed breakfast cereals, rice cakes, certain refined flour preparations, instant mashed potatoes, and heavily cooked then mashed potatoes generally contain a significant proportion of rapidly digestible starch.

But why?

Because food processing changes their physical structure.

When starch is heated in the presence of water, its granules swell, lose some internal organization, and become more accessible to enzymes. This phenomenon is called **gelatinization**.

Grinding, milling into flour, and certain industrial processes like extrusion can also facilitate starch digestion.

In other words, the food industry doesn’t just alter texture; it can change how quickly glucose becomes available.

Take a whole potato, homemade mashed potatoes, and instant mashed potatoes. The plant origin is similar, but the final structure is not.

In individuals with insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes, a large amount of rapidly available carbohydrates can contribute to particularly pronounced blood sugar spikes.

This does not mean that a portion of rapidly digestible starch alone causes disease. The amount consumed, energy balance, physical activity, and metabolic regulation capacity remain decisive.

**The real issue is not simply the presence of starch but the amount of glucose it can release and the speed at which the body must manage it.**

SECOND CATEGORY: SLOWLY DIGESTIBLE STARCH, OR SDS

Here is a fraction far less known to the general public.

SDS, or *Slowly Digestible Starch*, represents the starch hydrolyzed between twenty and one hundred twenty minutes in the reference enzymatic test.

It is also destined to be converted into glucose and absorbed in the small intestine, but its hydrolysis is more gradual.

This difference is important.

When glucose becomes available more slowly, the glycemic response can be more spread out over time, with a less pronounced peak than after an equivalent amount of rapidly digestible starch.

This is precisely why the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) recognized as early as 2011, under defined dietary conditions, a cause-and-effect relationship between replacing rapidly digestible starch with a sufficient proportion of slowly digestible starch and reducing post-meal glycemic response.

Which foods can contain a significant proportion of SDS?

Traditional durum wheat pasta, especially when it retains a compact structure, is a particularly interesting example. Some minimally processed cereals, intact grains, certain parboiled rice varieties, and several legumes can also have starch fractions digested more slowly.

The case of pasta is almost a demonstration in itself.

Bread and pasta can be made from very similar cereals. Yet, they do not necessarily provoke the same glycemic response.

Why?

Because the dense structure of pasta traps some starch within a protein matrix that temporarily limits enzyme access.

Experimental work published in *The Journal of Nutrition* precisely showed that pasta’s structure allows slower starch hydrolysis and a lower glycemic response than bread or couscous made from the same raw material.

This is why classifying foods solely by carbohydrate content can be misleading.

But beware of a second mistake: **slowly digestible does not mean non-digestible.**

SDS starch ultimately releases glucose for the most part. A large portion still means a large amount of digestible carbohydrates, even if absorption is more gradual.

For someone whose glycemic regulation is already impaired, this distinction matters greatly.

THIRD CATEGORY: RESISTANT STARCH, OR RS

This is probably the most surprising category.

Resistant starch, or *Resistant Starch*, refers to the fraction that escapes digestion in the small intestine and can reach the colon.

Unlike the first two categories, it does not directly provide the same amount of absorbable glucose in the small intestine.

Part of it can be fermented by intestinal microorganisms.

This fermentation produces short-chain fatty acids such as acetate, propionate, and butyrate.

Butyrate is an important energy substrate for colon cells and plays roles in mechanisms related to intestinal barrier integrity.

Where do we find this starch?

In green bananas, raw potato starch, certain high-amylose corn varieties, legumes, intact whole grains, and starchy foods cooked then cooled.

But there are several forms of resistant starch.

RS1 is physically protected by the structure of seeds or grains.

RS2 corresponds notably to some starch granules naturally resistant to hydrolysis, like those in green bananas or raw potatoes.

RS3 appears during **retrogradation**: after cooking, some starch chains reorganize during cooling and become less accessible to enzymes.

There are also technologically modified resistant starches called RS4, as well as starch-lipid complexes classified as RS5.

And here an astonishing phenomenon occurs.

HOW THE SAME FOOD CAN CHANGE CATEGORY

Imagine a freshly cooked portion of rice.

Cooking with water has made a significant part of its starch easily accessible to digestive enzymes.

Now imagine this rice is cooled for several hours in the refrigerator.

Part of its starch can reorganize into more resistant structures.

The total starch amount hasn’t mysteriously disappeared. But its distribution between digestible and resistant fractions has changed.

In 2022, a study involving 32 people with type 1 diabetes compared freshly prepared rice to rice cooled for twenty-four hours then reheated.

Researchers observed a significantly lower glycemic response after the cooled then reheated rice.

This result does not mean rice became carbohydrate-free. It shows that **food preparation can modify its metabolic availability**.

This phenomenon can also affect potatoes and certain pastas, with variable effects depending on recipes and preparation conditions.

In other words, it’s no longer enough to ask: “How many carbohydrates does this food contain?”

We must also understand the physical state of its starch.

THE CATCH: RESISTANT STARCH IS NOT AUTOMATICALLY BETTER FOR EVERYONE

One might be tempted to conclude that rapidly digestible starches are bad, slowly digestible ones are better, and resistant starches are the ultimate winners.

That would be a far too simplistic reading.

Resistant starch partly escapes enzymatic digestion but can become a fermentation substrate for the microbiota.

However, this fermentation is not necessarily comfortable for every individual.

In some people, especially those with visceral hypersensitivity or functional digestive disorders, increased fermentable substrates can cause gas, bloating, and distension.

This does not mean fermentation is automatically harmful or inflammatory. It means tolerance varies.

A systematic review of controlled trials published in *The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition* noted variable digestive effects depending on resistant starch types and doses.

Conversely, some clinical trials suggest metabolic benefits.

In 2024, a study published in *Nature Metabolism*, involving 37 overweight or obese individuals, observed that resistant starch supplementation for eight weeks could improve certain parameters related to weight and insulin resistance.

These results remain context-dependent and do not justify considering resistant starch as a universal treatment.

WHY THE GLYCEMIC INDEX DOESN’T TELL THE WHOLE STORY

The glycemic index is an interesting tool but answers a precise question: what is the glycemic response caused by a standardized amount of available carbohydrates from a food compared to a reference food?

It does not directly indicate the exact proportion of RDS, SDS, or RS starch.

It also does not measure the actual carbohydrate amount consumed in a typical portion, unlike glycemic load, which incorporates this quantity.

And it provides no information on colonic fermentation or digestive tolerance.

The RDS/SDS/RS classification thus provides essential complementary information: it focuses on starch’s fate during digestion.

On one side, we have a measure of the body’s response. On the other, a characterization of the food and its digestibility.

These are two different perspectives on the same biological phenomenon.

THE REAL CHALLENGE IS NOT TO FIND THE BEST STARCH

For someone who regularly consumes many starch-rich products, this classification helps better understand why food choice and processing can modify metabolic response.

But it does not answer all questions.

A physically active person with good insulin sensitivity will not necessarily respond like a sedentary, insulin-resistant, or diabetic individual.

Someone with digestive disorders may not tolerate increased resistant starch, even if it has interesting physiological properties.

This is also where low-carb or carnivore approaches offer another perspective: rather than systematically seeking to replace starch with a more slowly digested version, they allow a strong reduction or even elimination of this dietary glucose source.

This can profoundly alter post-meal glycemic response without guaranteeing resolution of all metabolic or digestive issues.

**The essential message is simple: starch is not a uniform substance. Its structure, cooking, processing, digestion speed, and the body’s capacity to manage it drastically change the outcome.**

For a long time, nutritional debates focused on simple versus complex carbohydrates, then on glycemic index.

The classification of rapidly digestible, slowly digestible, and resistant starches shows that biological reality is far more interesting.

And it leads to a question we should ask ourselves much more often:

**When we eat a starch-rich food, do we really know which fraction will be rapidly converted to glucose, which will be converted gradually, and which will reach our gut microbiota?**

---

Scientific References

**Englyst, Kingman, and Cummings (1992)** — *Classification and measurement of nutritionally important starch fractions*. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 46(Suppl. 2), S33–S50.

**EFSA (2011)** — *Slowly digestible starch in starch-containing foods and reduction of post-prandial glycaemic responses*. EFSA Journal, 9(7), 2292. [DOI: 10.2903/j.efsa.2011.2292](https://doi.org/10.2903/j.efsa.2011.2292)

**Pasta Structure Affects Mastication, Bolus Properties, and Postprandial Glucose and Insulin Metabolism in Healthy Adults (2021)** — The Journal of Nutrition. [Full study](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8971003/)

**Influence of resistant starch resulting from the cooling of rice on postprandial glycemia in type 1 diabetes (2022)** — Nutrition & Diabetes. [DOI: 10.1038/s41387-022-00196-1](https://doi.org/10.1038/s41387-022-00196-1)

**Resistant starch intake facilitates weight loss in humans by reshaping the gut microbiota (2024)** — Nature Metabolism. [DOI: 10.1038/s42255-024-00988-y](https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-024-00988-y)

**The impact of slowly digestible and resistant starch on glucose homeostasis and insulin resistance (2024)** — Current Opinion in Clinical Nutrition and Metabolic Care. [Full study](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11155281/)

**Tolerability and SCFA production after resistant starch supplementation in humans (2022)** — The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. [Systematic review](https://ajcn.nutrition.org/article/S0002-9165%2822%2900178-2/fulltext)

#Starch #GlycemicIndex #BloodSugar #Insulin #InsulinResistance #ResistantStarch #Digestion #Microbiota #Metabolism #Nutrition #LowCarb #AthleticCarnivore

Discussion around this article

Ask a question or add your feedback directly below the article. The comment appears on the page and can be removed from the admin area if needed.

No comment published yet. Start the discussion.

Share this article

Copy the link or share the article directly on your networks.

starchblood sugarglycemic indexdigestionresistant starchinsulinnutritionlow carbmicrobiotainsulin resistance
Athletic Carnivore Club

The reading continues in the discussions.

The comment above is for reacting directly to this article. The Club opens a longer, real discussion with members.

Read, understand, then act

The articles provide context. The questionnaire and the virtual coach then help you move forward based on your own situation.